Riley shows up and makes her nervous, causing her to call off the wedding. Right after Ben leaves for work, Emma takes her first steps, walking to Danny. Bonnie plans to use the opportunity to get close to Mr. Bonnie and Tucker begin betting on Danny's hockey games. Danny and Bonnie recover Riley's phone and attempt to delete the voicemail Bonnie sent.
Leaving Tucker and Danny needing to find a place to watch the match. An old home video of Ben, Danny, Riley and Sam at a homecoming party back in their high school days uncovers hidden secrets. After meeting with people representing Okiru, Bonnie still doesn't agree with the endorsement. Seeing Tucker depressed from online dating, Ben and Bonnie create a secret admirer for him with the photo of a model. Danny, Sam and Riley are inducted in their old high school athletic hall of fame, with Sam and Riley both being upset that Danny has a prime position in the school for his display while they get terrible ones.
After being told about the past romantic relationship between Ben and Riley, Ross demands that Ben not show up to the cocktail party that Riley is throwing. In the end, through a paternity test, it was revealed that David is Riley's father. Ben leaves Emma with Milena and crashes Riley's date with Fitch at a restaurant. While Angela is spending time with Emma, Ben asks Riley to keep an eye on them. Fitch dies, but is actually revealed to be alive when he makes an appearance at the eulogy with Riley now conflicted if she was ever in love with him. .
When Danny found out that Fitch wanted to break up with Riley during a video that he made but when she found out she said that she want to break up with him. And Gene says he knows why, revealing to Tucker, Danny, and Bonnie that he's up to something. Based on how they told him, Danny assumes it's Ben. When Riley discovers that Bonnie keeps taking her phone, Bonnie drops a glass of water. Georgie tells Danny that she is moving to Paris for her job at Vogue, with Danny contemplating on moving there with her. Tucker then reminisces about his ex-girlfriend from college named Olivia.
Bonnie lies about her age, as she is dating a younger guy named Brad. Ben then sets Riley up with Kevin , the beer delivery guy who frequents the Bar on B, with Ben giving Kevin false information on what to say on their date. Because Danny still has feelings for Riley, he questions if she wants to go through with it. At the boy's apartment, Danny tells riley that he doesn't remember anything from the incident. Ben breaks up with Cassie, because she thinks that Riley likes him, which Riley denies.
While in the care of Riley and Tucker, Emma falls out of a chair and gets stitches on her head, with Riley and Tucker attempting to hide Emma's injury from the Wheelers. Brad returns from Peru with a new bearded look and a new outlook on life, instantly turning off Bonnie. Riley suspects that Sam will use the getaway as an opportunity to make romantic moves on Ben, now that Sam knows that he has romantic feelings for Zoey, and Riley still wanting Ben and Zoey to be together. He takes care of Emma, with help from his mother Bonnie , his roommate Tucker , his best friend Riley , and his brother Danny. Ben also had a crush on her in high school and she was not very nice to Riley during that time. When that turns out to be a fluke, he looks for something else to try to expose him. Danny plays matchmaker for Riley to be set up with Gerard , the goalie on his team.
The guys try to hide from Bonnie by heading over to Riley's apartment, which ends up sabotaging her date with Jack. Then when Bonnie tries to fix it, she accidentally sends the voicemail to Riley. Ray arrives in town and Ben tries to get him and Bonnie back together. Not knowing about Philip, a misunderstanding from Bonnie, has her thinking that Riley has fallen for Danny. Ben then goes to see Riley to have her come back.
Ben discovers Riley and Fitch alone, and when Riley leaves, Fitch pulls out a wedding ring and puts it on his finger, which surprises Ben, but finally gives him something to expose. Bonnie wants to break up with Brad, but changes her mind after he ends up in the hospital and confesses his love for her. Danny begins seeing psychologist Dr. To get a promotion to television producer, Tucker books Danny on 's talk show. However, Ben decides to keep Emma and raise her. After getting kicked off the cruise because of Bonnie's shenanigans, Danny and Riley finally tie the knot at Ben and Tucker's place.